Advanced Search  
JWJ > Volume 35(1); 2017 > Article
Deshpande, Kshirsagar, and Dharmadhikari: Optimization of GMAW Process Parameters to Improve the Length of Penetration in EN 10025 S 235 Grade

Abstract

In auto ancillary fabrication industry, GMAW is a very useful & important welding process and EN10025 S 235 Grade is common material used for manufacturing of two wheeler chassis. This research gives the detail influence of welding process parameters such as welding current, welding voltage, wire speed on the penetration in EN10025 S 235 Grade mild steel material. The experimentation of this research has been carried out by using three factors, three level Taguchi DOE method. To analyze & optimize the welding parameters & characteristics, analysis of variance, L9 orthogonal array & signal to noise ratio are used. Length of Penetration in addition to the depth of penetration is major concern in fillet welded joints, as the penetration decides the strength of the welded joint. After analysis of penetration in all 9 welded samples, optimize parameters readings verified & found probability value within 0.05. From this research it is come to know that welding current & welding voltage is major parameters which affects the penetration in welded joints.

1. Introduction

Gas metal arc welding is a welding process which has various industrial applications. In GMAW an electric arc produced between electrode & work piece metals, this causes electrode & work piece metal to melt and join1). The joining area is called as weld4). GMAW process parameters affecting the quality of welding & productivity. In auto ancillary fabrication industry length of penetration is one of the most important factors which should achieve during welding. This Length of penetration is measured at depth of T/20 and minimum requirement of which is 0.8xT so as to get optimum weld strength where T is thickness of metal to be welded. The input parameters which are mainly responsible for welding penetration is welding current, welding voltage, welding speed & these parameters plays an important role in achieving the desired penetration in welded joints. In this research work, EN 10025 S 235 Grade mild steel material has been used with specimen size of 100 × 80 × 3mm. Design of experiments based on Taguchi technique is used to evaluate the data. An orthogonal array, signal to noise (S/N) ratio and analysis of variance (ANOVA) has been used to find the best welding penetration in mild steel materials by using different range of input parameters.
We have used Taguchi DOE method for the experimentation as the method is an efficient method for optimization of process parameters. The method was developed by Dr. Genichi Taguchi, who was a Japanese quality management consultant; the method is based on orthogonal array experiments, which gives reduced optimum setting of process control parameters. The method was selected for the experimentation because the method is cost effective, less time consuming, greater accuracy, and robust design for large scale application. By using Taguchi method for process parameters optimization Design of Experiments (DOE) were selected. For the experimentation 3 factors & 3 level Taguchi design model was used, Based on this model we have generated L9 orthogonal array & total 9 runs were taken for the experiment. Minitab 15.0 software was used to generate the orthogonal array through Taguchi Design.

2. Experimental Procedure

2.1 Sample preparation

Fig. 1
Photographic view of GMA welding machine
jwj-35-1-74f1.tif
Table 1
EN 10025 S 235 Grade Material Properties
Chemical Analysis C (%) Mn (%) Cr (%) Ni (%) Mo (%) S (%) P (%) Cu (%)
Specified 0.19 max 1.50 max ~~~ ~~~ ~~~ 0.045 max 0.045 max 0.60 max
Observed 0.19 0.89 0.02 0.02 0.009 0.014 0.005 0.027
Mechanical Properties Hardness Tensile Strength Yield Strength % of Elongation
Standard ~~~ 365-510 N/mm2 235 N/mm2 min 15% min
Observed 70-76 HRB 452.65 N/mm2 392.47 N/mm2 29.55%
Table 2
Filler Wire Material Properties
Material Description : Copper Coated Wire used in GMA Welding Process
Material Specification: American Welding Society A5.18 Grade ER70-S6
Size : Dia.0.8 mm
Chemical Analysis C (%) Mn (%) Si (%) S(%) P (%) Cu (%)
Specified 0.07-0.15 1.40-1.85 0.80-1.15 0.035 max 0.025 max 0.50 max
Observed 0.129 1.58 0.87 0.03 0.019 0.3
Mechanical Properties UTS (Mpa) Yield Strength (Mpa) Elongation (%) Impact Properties (CVN) Average (J) Temperature (˚C)
Standard 480 Min 400 Min 22 Min 27 -30
Observed 1333.36 430 28.5 27 -30
We have used Gas Metal Arc Welding process for the experimentation, as the process has high weld deposition efficiency & better weld quality with low operation cost. Experiments were carried out by using semiautomatic controlled GMAW processAK 600AMP welding machine. Copper coated steel wire of ER70 S6 grade with 0.8 mm diameter in the coil form was used for the welding. Shielding gas Ar-C02 used for shielding purpose with percentage of Ar: 82% & CO2:18%2).
Mild Steel plate EN10025 S 235 Grade used as base material with specimen size of 100 × 80 × 3mm. The welding is carried out in 2F welding position & the joint taken for welding was Tee joint. The welding is done by the qualified welder and is done as per the guidelines of EN ISO 15609-13).

2.2 Experimental Procedure.

2.2.1 Selection of important process parameters

The controllable process parameters6) were selected conduct the experiments are Current, Voltage &Wire speed. The objective of this study as discussed earlier is to optimize the welding process parameters for enhancing weld penetration. A total of the three welding process parameters were chosen as the controlling factors.

2.2.2 To decide the upper & lower limits process parameters

The selection of upper & lower limit of process parameters has been done on the basis of machine manufacturer ESAB guideline & standards which is based on filler wire diameter, shielding gas percentage & type of weld joint.

2.2.3 Development of orthogonal array

A matrix experiments consists of a set of experiments where the settings of the various products or process parameters are changed that which are to be studied from one experiment to another. After conducting a matrix experiment the data from all experiments in the set taken together are analyzed to determine the effects of several parameters. Conducting matrix experiments using special matrices, called Orthogonal Array7), allows the effects of several parameters to be determined efficiently and is an important technique in Parameter Design.
L9 orthogonal array5) was developed by using 3 factors & 3 levels Taguchi design.
Experimentation for the welding process as per the parameters mentioned in orthogonal array8)

2.2.4 Preparation of samples & experimental trials

Total 09 Nos. of trials conducted as defined in orthogonal array sampling plan, test piece used for
the trials as per the defined size (100×80×3 mm)

2.2.5 Penetration inspection

After preparation of all 09 Nos. of samples, length of penetration is measured by taking cut section of all samples & using semi automatic micro graphical microscope (Rapid-I designed by Customised techonologies Bangalore, India).
Fig. 2
Sample preparation
jwj-35-1-74f2.tif
Microscope with embedded camera can be controlled and programmed using computer. For the ease of operation already saved program can be used and real time reports are generated in generic format.
Table 3
Level of Process Parameters
Levels Current (A) Voltage (V) Wire Speed (m/min)
1 160 16 8
2 190 19 10
3 220 22 12

2.2.6 Analyze Taguchi design

To analyze the Taguchi Design, Signal to Noise(S/N) ratio calculated5). As we required maximum length of penetration as a result, larger is better option was selected. After experimentation, S/N ratio calculated through the penetration reading.
Graph for the response table for SN Ratios & Response table for Means can be plotted as follows
As it can be seen from main effects plot for SN ratio and main effects plot for means; favorable outcome i.e. optimal (maximum) length of penetration will be at a combination of A-1, B-2, C-3. If seen at combinations obtained through L-9 orthogonal array; there is no such combination exists as stated above, so for verification new sample is prepared with parameter combination as A-1 current 160 A, B-2 voltage 19 V and C-3 wire speed 12 m/min. And after doing routine procedure for penetration inspection; the length of penetration is observed as 7.2334 mm which is higher than the lengths of penetration observed earlier.
Thus from this we can say that optimal set of parameters to get optimal(maximum) length of penetration for EN 10025 S 235 grade material is 160 A current, 19V voltage and 12 m/min wire speed.
Table 4
Sampling plan for process parameters as per taguchi method
Process Parameter Sample 1 Sample 2 Sample 3 Sample 4 Sample 5 Sample 6 Sample 7 Sample 8 Sample 9
Current (A) 160 160 160 190 190 190 220 220 220
Voltage (V) 16 19 22 16 19 22 16 19 22
Wire Speed (M/min) 8 10 12 10 12 8 12 8 10
Table 5
S/N Ratio calculation
ORTHOGONAL ARRAY AND CORROSPONDING RESULTS
Sr No A B C length of pentration SNRA1 MEAN1
1 1 1 1 4.5274 13.1170 4.5274
2 1 2 2 6.1288 15.7475 6.1288
3 1 3 3 6.1099 15.7207 6.1099
4 2 1 2 4.5093 13.0822 4.5093
5 2 2 3 5.8477 15.3397 5.8477
6 2 3 1 3.88 11.7766 3.8800
7 3 1 3 4.1005 12.2567 4.1005
8 3 2 1 3.8904 11.7999 3.8904
9 3 3 2 3.7589 11.5012 3.7589

2.2.7 Adequacy of the model

Fig. 3
Main effects plot for S/N ratio
jwj-35-1-74f3.tif
Table 6
Response for S/N ratios; larger is better
Level A B C
1 14.86 12.89 12.23
2 13.39 14.29 13.69
3 8.19 12.99 14.43
Delta 6.67 1.40 2.20
Rank 1 3 2
Table 7
Response table for means
Level A B C
1 5.59 4.38 4.09
2 4.75 5.29 4.80
3 3.92 4.58 5.35
Delta 1.67 0.91 1.26
Rank 1 3 2
The model checked for the adequacy by using ANOVA i.e. Analysis of Variance Method.
As per ANOVA, the value of P should be less than 0.05 for every parameter for the desired adequacy & it has been confirmed that the model is adequate from the below results.
General Linear Model: SNRA1 versus A, B, C.

2.2.8 Optimum process parameters

Regardless of the category of the quality characteristic, a greater S/N ratio corresponds to better quality characteristics. Therefore, the optimal level with the greatest S/N ratio. The optimal levels of process are:
From the graph of S/N Ratio & mean values
Current - A 1 = 160 A
Voltage - B 2 = 19 V
Wire Speed - C 3 = 12 m/min.

3. Conclusion

The present study is carried to discuss an application of the Taguchi Method for obtaining the maximum length of penetration. We have conducted various trials for the optimization of process parameters & reach to following conclusion.
1) Optimization of process parameters can be effectively done by using 3 levels, 3 factors & L9 orthogonal array
2) Better penetration observed is 7.2334 mm at Current 160 A, Voltage 19 V, Wire Speed 12 M/min

4. Acknowledgement

The authors would like to acknowledge the support for experimental set up rendered by Mr. Shekhar Thorat (Executive Director & Unit Head) of M/s Metalman Auto Pvt. Ltd., Aurangabad. Maharashtra, India.

References

1. Weldability, An Introduction to MIG welding WWS Group

2. The Linde Group (Formerly British Oxygen Company Ltd.). AU: IPRM 200, Section 8: Consumables.

3. ISO 15609-1:2004. Specification and qualification of welding procedures for metallic materials Welding procedure specification.

4. Ambekar S.D, Wadhokar S.R. Parametric optimization of gas metal arc welding process by using Taguchi method on stainless steel AISI 410. International Journal of Research in Modern Engineering and Emerging Technology. 3 (1) (2015)

5. Deshmukh1 Pradeep, Teli S. N. Parametric optimization of SAW Welding Parameters using Taguchi L9 array. International Journal of Engineering, Business and Enterprise Applications. (2014), 45s–57s

6. Sreeraj P, Kannan T, Maji Subhasis. Prediction and optimization of weld bead geometry in gas metal arc welding process using RSM and fmincon. Journal of Mechanical Engineering Research. 5 (8) (2013), 154–165 DOI 10.5897/JMER2013.0292
crossref
7. Utkarsh S, Neel P, Mahajan Mayank T, Jignesh P, Prajapati R. B. Experimental investigation of MIG welding for ST-37 using design of experiment. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications. 4 (5) (2014)

8. Satyaduttsinh P. Chavda, Jayesh V. Desai, Tushar M. Patel. A review on optimization of MIG Welding parameters using Taguchi’s DOE method. International Journal of Engineering and Management research. 1 (2014), 16–21

TOOLS
PDF Links  PDF Links
PubReader  PubReader
ePub Link  ePub Link
Full text via DOI  Full text via DOI
Download Citation  Download Citation
CrossRef TDM  CrossRef TDM
  E-Mail
  Print
Share:      
METRICS
0
Crossref
2,519
View
60
Download
Related articles
Optimization of GTAW Parameters for Horizontal Welding of a STS316L Pipe  2015 October;33(5)
Optimization of Process Parameters Using a Genetic Algorithm for Process Automation in Aluminum Laser Welding with Filler Wire  2006 October;24(5)
A Study on an Optimization of Welding Process Parameters by using an Analytic Solution for the Welding Angular Distortion  2003 December;21(7)
Optimization of GTAW Parameters for Horizontal Welding of a STS316L Pipe  2015 October;33(5)
Optimization of Process Parameters Using a Genetic Algorithm for Process Automation in Aluminum Laser Welding with Filler Wire  2006 October;24(5)
A Study on an Optimization of Welding Process Parameters by using an Analytic Solution for the Welding Angular Distortion  2003 December;21(7)
e-sciencecentral
Register for e-submission
Register here to access the e-submission system of Journal of Welding and Joining for authors and reviewers.
Manuscript Submission
To submit a manuscript, please visit the Journal of Welding and Joining e-submission management system at http://submit.e-jwj.org, read the Instructions for Authors, and log into the Journal of Welding and Joining e-submission system. For assistance with manuscript submission, please contact: koweld@kwjs.or.kr.
Free archive
Anyone may access any past or current articles without logging in.
Editorial Office
The Korea Science and Technology Building, New B/D, Room 503
Teheran-ro 7-gil, 22(635-4, Yeoksam-Dong), Gangnam-gu, Seoul 06130, Korea
TEL : +82-2-538-6511    FAX : +82-2-538-6510   E-mail: koweld@kwjs.or.kr
Browse Articles |  Current Issue |  For Authors and Reviewers |  About
Copyright© by The Korean Welding and Joining Society. All right reserved.